A Policy to Evade International Law In the aftermath of the September 11 attacks on the United States, the Bush administration seemingly determined that winning the war on terror required that the United States circumvent international law. Indeed, in response to a legal challenge by several detainees, the U. Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeldsaid, overlooking that the Geneva Conventions provide explicit protections to all persons captured in an international armed conflict, even if they are not entitled to POW status.
Converting the massive complex into a prison operated by coalition forces in August, [iii] military personnel took charge of incoming prisoners. The prison operated under Army reserve brigadier general, Janis Karpinski, who also looked after two other large jails and had never experienced any training in handling prisoners.
There were three categories differentiating the prisoners: As one may expect, Abu Ghraib sits in a particularly hostile area within Iraq. A Newsweek article discusses the adrenaline producing events the prison guards had to work in, citing snipers firing on U.
For example, Major General Geoffrey Miller the former commander at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba was put in charge of increasing interrogation means to procure more information from the prisoners. While Ryder may have covered up the indecent acts that were occurring at Abu Ghraib, military police Specialist Joseph M.
There were even some pictures of dead prisoners, possibly murdered by individuals attempting to obtain information.
The aim of this article is to picture the malpractice that was committed during the so-called ‘war on terror,’ with particular attention being paid to the Abu Ghraib prison (in Baghdad) and in the US base in Guantanamo Bay in Cuba. Abu Ghraib and Insaniyat Article by: Arshin Adib-Moghaddam “We have met the enemy, and he is us” Iraq is a different world than where we live in North America. The case study is ultimately intended to illuminate a similar case of empire and belief, namely, the United States in Iraq in the twenty-first century under evangelical Christian President George W. Bush. Lincoln is particularly interested in comparing Bush's articulated motives .
Most of these pictures are taken with U. The inmates at Abu Ghraib experienced the most horrific dehumanization that anyone can relate to, particularly because the Islamic laws strictly forbid homosexual acts and even nudity in front of other men.
Despite these swift and encompassing allegations, all of the accused members pointed their fingers right back at their higher ranking officers, accusing them of ordering such actions to take place.
For starters, there was a severe deficiency in guards for the over 7, detainees that were housed in Abu Ghraib. From these two standpoints, an inevitable question arises: Does a governmental entity operate under the same ethics as a business?
For the ethical analysis that I put this case study under, I presume that a government entity should operate under the same ethics as a business. To conclude, I validate the unethical nature of the tortures at Abu Ghraib.
This ethical theory outlines three formulations upon which an ethical behavior is grounded. First, Kant believed that one must attribute a maxim to every behavior he ensues, then evaluate what would happen if everyone enacted upon that maxim.
Lastly, Kant believed that each and every person within an organization must follow the golden rule: Finally the military police did not act with dignity and respect to the individuals in their captivity because they caused physical and emotional harm to the prisoners without discretion.
Therefore, all three components of the categorical imperative have been violated by the prison guards.
Though we can see that the behaviors of the Abu Ghraib prison guards are unethical from a Kantian perspective, there are theories that dispute this claim. This argument describes how acting in a socially responsible way simply means that an executive is not acting in the best interest of her employer, thus she is disregarding her responsibility as an executive.Star-Ledger file photo Recently released government documents show Javal Sean Davis of Roselle, jailed for abusive treatment of prisoners at Abu Ghraib while serving with the Army in Iraq, may have been just carrying out orders.
p.m., Dec. 7, The torture of detainees by U.S.
soldiers at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq was the tragic result of perceived anonymity, the absence of a sense of personal responsibility and tacit approval by military commanders, factors that have been shown in experiments to make good people do evil, Philip G.
Zimbardo, professor emeritus of psychology at Stanford University, said at UD. Jul 11, · These are the sources and citations used to research CASE STUDY WORDS CRIMES OF THE POWERFUL ABU GHRAIB.
This bibliography was generated on Cite This For Me on Saturday, August 5, Fair pricing, starting only at $10 per page; Timely delivery; Expert experienced writers; 0% Plagiarism Principle; Absolutely Free revisions where necessary.
Case Study: Cain and Abel. This case presents a situation in which all concerned will benefit financially by ignoring the conflict of interest. It is crucial to remember that this is an incomplete view of the situation and even on financial grounds is very short-sighted.
What we actually have is a case in which all concerned would argue.
Abu Ghraib and Insaniyat Article by: Arshin Adib-Moghaddam “We have met the enemy, and he is us” Iraq is a different world than where we live in North America. Canadian values and culture of North America are vastly different from those of the Middle Eastern country that is the subject of an-article by Arshin Adib-Moghaddam titled Abu Gharib and Insaniyat.